NYPD ends program that spied on Muslim communities
The New York Police Department has disbanded a clandestine unit of plainclothes detectives that ran detailed, invasive spying operations targeting the city’s Muslim communities.
The NYPD’s vast surveillance detail eventually led to multiple legal challenges and outrage among citizens, especially the targeted communities already under scrutiny following the September 11, 2001 attacks.
The Demographics Unit, as the surveillance squad was known, drilled into various neighborhoods both inside and outside the city, analyzing and mapping religious institutions, social clubs, recreational facilities and events, and all-around everyday life.
“The Demographics Unit created psychological warfare in our community,” said Linda Sarsour of the Arab American Association of New York, according to The New York Times.
“Those documents, they showed where we live. That’s the cafe where I eat. That’s where I pray. That’s where I buy my groceries. They were able to see their entire lives on those maps. And it completely messed with the psyche of the community,” Sarsour added.
NYPD Commissioner Bill Bratton and his top staff members met with Sarsour and other advocates last week. She said the department’s intelligence chief, John Miller, said the NYPD did not need a covert team to monitor Muslims in the city, implicating that the unit would not last much longer.
The team of surveillance operatives started its work in 2003, with the help of CIA officer Lawrence Sanchez while he was also working with the NYPD. The unit was later renamed the Zone Assessment Unit. It has been mostly inactive since Bratton – and Mayor Bill de Blasio – took over in January, NYPD spokesman Stephen Davis said.
“Understanding certain local demographics can be a useful factor when assessing the threat information that comes into New York City virtually on a daily basis,” Davis said.
“In the future, we will gather that information, if necessary, through direct contact between the police precincts and the representatives of the communities they serve.”
The unit’s aim was to understand possible locations and “hot spots” of radicalization where a would-be Islamic militant could hide in plain sight. Thus, the squad of about a dozen members could assess possible signs of budding terror plots.
Detectives were encouraged to engage employees of Muslim-owned businesses to “gauge sentiment” about American foreign policy issues and other political issues.
The unit had mapped and photographed common meeting spots for, say, Egyptians to watch soccer or Albanians to play chess.
The spying operations were buttressed by informants that gathered information on Muslim student groups, as well as the actions of Muslim scholars on college campuses.
The unit designated many mosques as suspected “terrorism enterprises,” thus allowing them to collect license plate numbers of any car in mosque parking lots, secretly film anyone attending a service, and record sermons via bugged informants.
Yet despite investigations of mosques that lasted years, the department never levied terror charges against a mosque or Islamic organization. In fact, after years of gathering information, the NYPD admitted the program not once generated a lead.
The program was exposed by the Associated Press in 2011, and violated groups - along with civil rights defenders - have called for its shuttering ever since.
Though the Demographics Unit has been disbanded, it remains to be seen what comes of these programs. Though former police commissioner Ray Kelly vigorously defended the operations as lawful and a vital protection from terrorist attacks, the unit’s actions came under significant legal scrutiny.
Last month, a federal judge dismissed a lawsuit over the surveillance program, claiming Muslims could not prove harm by the spying. Two other federal lawsuits challenging the NYPD’s tactics remain.
